La Porte Property Damage Attorneys
When your home or business is hit by an unexpected fire, powerful storm, or flooding in La Porte, your property insurance should serve as a dependable path to recovery. Yet, navigating complex, high-value insurance claims is rarely straightforward. If your insurer is postponing payments, proposing undervalued settlements, or refusing coverage for your commercial property, the dedicated attorneys at Ashford DiMartino & Jones are prepared to step in and advocate for your interests.

Our Local Indiana Team Fights For YOU
Expert Guidance: Navigating Your Property Damage Claim
We’ve compiled the following resources to help you understand your rights, hold insurers accountable, and maximize your recovery in La Porte.
Table of Contents
Understanding Property Damage Claims in La Porte, Indiana

When a devastating fire reduces your custom home to rubble or severe weather wreaks havoc on your commercial property, you depend on your insurance coverage to help you rebuild your life or business. Unfortunately, navigating property insurance claims can be a complex and often frustrating process. Residents of La Porte frequently find themselves facing delays, low settlements, or outright denials from their insurance providers. That’s where the dedicated legal team at Ashford DiMartino & Jones steps in.
Serving La Porte and Northwest Indiana
Our firm is committed to advocating for families, businesses, and organizations across La Porte and the surrounding Northwest Indiana region. From homeowners to condominium associations, we assist those who have encountered challenges with their insurance policy or experienced a breach in trust from their insurers. Additionally, we serve public adjusters who need legal guidance when helping clients with significant loss claims.
Navigating Complex Property Insurance Policies in Indiana
Property insurance policies serve as binding contracts between policyholders and insurance companies. In Indiana, these contracts are developed on a "take it or leave it" basis. However, state law offers protections designed to create a fairer landscape for individuals and business owners in La Porte.
The Rule of Ambiguity
Sometimes, the language within insurance policies can be vague—such as definitions of "storm damage" or "accidental loss." Indiana courts interpret ambiguous terms in favor of the policyholder rather than the insurance company.
Interpretation from the Ordinary Policyholder’s Perspective
Insurance language is judged from the perspective of a typical person rather than a legal professional. This guideline ensures that insurers cannot exploit complex terminology to dodge valid claims.
Clear Language Enforced as Written
If the policy's wording is straightforward, Indiana courts will uphold it as stated, even if this results in limited coverage.
The Duty of Good Faith in Handling Large-Loss Claims
In Indiana, all insurance policies implement an implied duty of good faith, obligating insurers to treat policyholders fairly. This becomes critical during large-loss circumstances—like catastrophic commercial property damage or the total loss of a home—where bad faith tactics can greatly delay recovery and add financial strain.
Examples of Bad Faith Practices Include:
- Unjustifiably refusing valid claims.
- Causing undue delays in processing claims, especially following significant disasters in La Porte.
- Denying claims without adequate investigation.
- Offering settlements that are substantially lower than the actual damages, compelling policyholders to pursue litigation.
Is Your Insurance Coverage Adequate?
For homeowners and business owners in La Porte, financial setbacks can also arise due to insufficient insurance coverage. Insurance agents have a responsibility to exercise reasonable care when arranging policies on behalf of clients, yet they are not required to recommend every possible coverage option.
Understanding the Special Relationship Exception:
Certain conditions may indicate a "special relationship" between a policyholder and their insurance agent, requiring a higher level of care. Courts take into account:
- Whether the agent provides specialized advice catered to unique risks.
- If the agent positions themselves as an expert, influencing the policyholder's reliance on that expertise.
- The extent of the agent's authority in selecting and managing coverage.
Moreover, if an agent gives explicit assurances about coverage—such as promises regarding high-value items—this could lead to their legal accountability if those representations prove inaccurate.
Our Focus on High-Value Property Damage Claims
At Ashford DiMartino & Jones, we specialize in significant property damages and catastrophic loss claims. Whether you’re the owner of a commercial property, a high-value residence, or managing a condominium association, our legal team is prepared to handle the complexities of litigation in La Porte and beyond.
Commercial Claims
We represent businesses in La Porte facing severe interruptions and significant property damages, including:
- Commercial Fire & Smoke Damage
- Commercial Water Damage
- Commercial Storm & Wind Damage
- Commercial "Bad Faith" Insurance Denials
Residential Claims
We advocate for homeowners striving to recover from substantial losses, including:
- Large-Loss Residential Fire Claims
- Residential Water Damage Claims
- Residential Roof & Storm Damage Claims
- Residential "Bad Faith" Insurance Denials
(Note: We also have dedicated hubs for our neighbors in Merrillville and Portage.)
NWI Service Locations
Meet Your La Porte Insurance Coverage Attorneys
C. Anthony “Tony” Ashford
Partner / Ashford DiMartino & Jones
Guy S. DiMartino
Partner / Ashford DiMartino & Jones
Angela M. Jones
Partner / Ashford DiMartino & Jones
Our Expertise is Your Asset
With over two decades of legal practice each, C. Anthony “Tony” Ashford and Guy S. DiMartino have built strong reputations for resolving disputes, litigating complex matters, and advising businesses as both internal and external counsel. They work together to support families, businesses, and organizations—such as homeowners and condominium associations—who are facing insurance-related challenges or claim denials.
Angela M. Jones is an experienced trial lawyer with more than ten years of practice in personal injury, commercial litigation, business law, and municipal matters. She is widely respected for her strategic litigation approach and unwavering dedication to achieving positive outcomes for her clients.
In 2024, Angela secured an $8.25 million verdict in Cosme v. Erie Insurance, an insurance bad faith case that received statewide attention and ranked among Indiana’s largest jury awards. Prior to trial, she achieved a unanimous ruling at the Indiana Supreme Court, demonstrating her ability to deliver results at every level.
Ready to Fight Back? Contact Our Firm Today
When dealing with a substantial commercial loss or serious damage to a high-value home, it is important not to let the insurance company determine the direction of your recovery.
Reach out to Ashford DiMartino & Jones today. Defend your property, preserve your business, and allow our experienced trial attorneys to hold the insurance company responsible.
Get A Free Claim Review