Northwest Indiana Property Damage Attorneys
When a major storm with powerful winds, unexpected floods, or devastating fires affects your home or business in Northwest Indiana, your property insurance should offer a helpful path toward recovery. However, handling complex, high-value insurance claims is often far from straightforward leading to frustration or feelings of hopelessness. If your insurance provider is presenting inadequate settlement offers, delaying payment, or denying coverage for your commercial property, the experienced attorneys at Ashford DiMartino & Jones are prepared to move in to advocate on your behalf.

Our Local Indiana Team Fights For YOU
Expert Guidance: Navigating Your Property Damage Claim
We’ve compiled the following resources to help you understand your rights, hold insurers accountable, and maximize your recovery in Northwest Indiana.
Table of Contents
Northwest Indiana Property Damage Attorneys: Your Ally After Catastrophic Events

Experiencing a severe fire at your cherished custom home or facing the aftermath of destructive storms impacting your business can be overwhelming. In such critical times, property insurance serves as a crucial support system for recovery. However, the intricacies of substantial insurance claims can create significant challenges. If you find your insurance company delaying payments, offering insufficient settlements, or outright denying your coverage for your commercial property, the dedicated attorneys at Ashford DiMartino & Jones are here to assist you.
Based in Valparaiso and serving the Northwest Indiana area, we are advocates for families, businesses, and organizations—including homeowners and condominium associations—navigating insurance policy challenges or unsatisfactory claim processes. We also support public adjusters facing obstacles in securing rightful payments for their clients.
Navigating Property Insurance Complexities in Indiana
Insurance policies can often resemble intricate contracts between policyholders and insurers. Indiana law, however, offers essential protections that help to level the playing field for individuals and commercial property owners in Valparaiso.
Understanding the Rule of Ambiguity
The language used in insurance documents can sometimes be vague, leading to misunderstandings about terms like "storm damage" or "accidental loss." In Indiana, if policy language allows for multiple interpretations, courts typically rule in favor of the policyholder.
Translating Legal Jargon for the Average Policyholder
Indiana courts interpret insurance policy language from the perspective of an average person, rather than a legal expert, ensuring that policyholders are not disadvantaged by overly complex terminology that could unjustly validate a denial of legitimate claims.
Clarity in Insurance Agreements
While clarity in insurance documentation can be beneficial, if the wording is straightforward and unambiguous, Indiana courts will uphold it as it is, even if it limits coverage in specific scenarios.
Holding Insurers to Their Obligations: The Duty of Good Faith in Large-Loss Claims
All insurance policies in Indiana carry an implied duty of good faith, requiring insurers to treat clients fairly during the claims process. In cases of significant loss, such as damage to property or home, unfair practices by insurers can inflict severe financial strain on policyholders.
Examples of Bad Faith Practices Under Indiana’s Claim Settlement Standards:
- Unjustly denying valid claims.
- Unwarranted delays in claim assessments or payments, particularly after events such as severe storms or fires in Valparaiso.
- Inadequate investigations prior to claim denials.
- Undervaluing settlements to pummel policyholders toward litigation.
Are You Underinsured? Evaluating Your Coverage Needs
For both homeowners and businesses in Valparaiso, the repercussions of having insufficient insurance can be significant. While agents are required to show reasonable diligence in securing requested coverage, they are not obliged to present every available option or guarantee complete protection for policyholders.
The “Special Relationship” Doctrine
In certain cases, an insurance agent may bear a heightened duty of care if a "special relationship" is established. Factors considered by courts include:
- Providing specialized advice based on unique risks, such as commercial operations in Valparaiso.
- Positioning themselves as authorities in insurance matters and earning the trust of clients.
- Having considerable influence over the selection and management of insurance policies.
Moreover, if an agent makes definite assurances—like asserting that high-value property or commercial activities are thoroughly insured—and you rely on those assurances, they may be held liable.
Types of Significant Property Damage Claims We Handle in Valparaiso
Our legal expertise is concentrated in high-value property damage claims. Whether you manage a commercial establishment, own a luxury home, or oversee a condominium association, our legal team is equipped to handle complex litigation throughout Valparaiso and Porter County.
Commercial Property Claims
We assist Valparaiso businesses affected by significant interruptions due to property damage, including:
- Fire and smoke impacts on commercial establishments.
- Water damage disrupting operations.
- Storm and wind damage to commercial properties.
- Claims denials based on bad faith tactics.
Residential Property Claims
We are unwavering advocates for homeowners as they work to rebuild following catastrophic incidents, such as:
- Major residential fire incidents.
- Water damage impacting homes.
- Roof and storm damage to residential properties.
- Denials rooted in bad faith practices against homeowners.
(Note: We also have dedicated hubs for multiple cities in Northwest Indiana.)
NWI Service Locations
Meet Your Northwest Indiana Insurance Coverage Attorneys
C. Anthony “Tony” Ashford
Partner / Ashford DiMartino & Jones
Guy S. DiMartino
Partner / Ashford DiMartino & Jones
Angela M. Jones
Partner / Ashford DiMartino & Jones
Our Expertise is Your Asset
C. Anthony “Tony” Ashford and Guy S. DiMartino each have more than 20 years of experience representing clients in complex legal matters. Over the years, they have negotiated settlements, litigated difficult cases, spoken on insurance litigation topics, and served as trusted counsel to businesses. Their work centers on protecting families, businesses, and organizations—including homeowner and condominium associations—facing insurance disputes.
Angela M. Jones brings over a decade of experience as a trial attorney handling personal injury, business litigation, commercial transactions, and municipal law matters. She is known for her strategic approach and tenacity in advocating for her clients.
In 2024, Angela achieved an $8.25 million jury verdict in Cosme v. Erie Insurance, a high-profile insurance bad faith case recognized statewide. She also secured a unanimous Indiana Supreme Court decision before trial, demonstrating her effectiveness in complex litigation.
Ready to Fight Back? Contact Our Firm Today
When facing a major commercial loss or significant damage to a high-value home, you should not allow the insurance company to control the outcome of your recovery.
Contact Ashford DiMartino & Jones today. Safeguard your property, protect your business, and let our skilled trial attorneys pursue accountability against the insurance company.
Get A Free Claim Review