Northwest Indiana Water & Flood Damage Attorneys

 

Recovering from water or flood damage to your home or commercial property in Northwest Indiana takes more than just time—it requires the full financial backing of your insurance policy. Unfortunately, insurance providers across the region often make the water and flood damage claims process difficult and frustrating for policyholders. If you are facing a delayed payout, a reduced water damage settlement, or an outright claim denial, the experienced water and flood damage attorneys at Ashford DiMartino & Jones are here to hold your insurer accountable and help you move forward.

Our Local Indiana Team Fights For YOU

Quick Case Fact: In 2024, Angela Jones secured an $8.25 million jury verdict in Cosme v. Erie Insurance, an insurance bad faith case that drew statewide attention and recognition, ranking among Indiana’s largest verdicts of the year. 

Expert Guidance: Navigating Your Water & Flood Damage Claim

We’ve compiled the following resources to help you understand your rights, hold insurers accountable, and maximize your recovery in Northwest Indiana.

Navigating Water Damage Claims in Northwest Indiana: Essential Insights

 

 

Experiencing water damage can be a harrowing ordeal for both property owners and tenants. In the wake of such incidents, individuals often turn to their insurance policies for the necessary financial assistance to restore their homes or businesses. However, the process of filing water damage claims is frequently fraught with challenges. If you find yourself facing claim denials, delayed responses, or settlements that don’t reflect your losses, the dedicated legal team at Ashford DiMartino & Jones is prepared to support you.

 

Understanding Water Damage Insurance Claims in Indiana

In Indiana, an insurance policy serves as a legal agreement between the policyholder and the insurance provider. While these contracts provide important coverage, they can often be skewed to favor the insurer. To better navigate water damage claims, it’s crucial to familiarize yourself with Indiana’s regulations regarding property insurance:

The Rule of Ambiguity

A significant concept in insurance disputes is the "Rule of Ambiguity." This principle indicates that if any terms in your insurance policy are vague—such as the definition of "water damage"—you may have more leverage. Courts in Indiana tend to interpret ambiguous language in favor of the policyholder, which can be advantageous during negotiations.

The Ordinary Policyholder’s Perspective

Insurers must interpret policy language as it would be understood by an "ordinary policyholder." This requirement prevents companies from exploiting complex legal terminology that may confuse the average individual. As a result, if the language is convoluted, courts might be inclined to rule in your favor.

The Importance of Clear Language

While ambiguity can work to your advantage, explicit terms in your insurance contract will generally be enforced as written. This means that if your policy articulates certain exclusions or limitations in clear language, Indiana courts will uphold these provisions, even if it means the insurer avoids a payout.

 

Ensuring Equity in Water Damage Claims

Indiana law mandates that insurance providers act in good faith when processing claims. This expectation is particularly significant when handling severe effects from water damage. Instances of bad faith can include:

  • Unjust Claim Denials: Refusal to honor a claim without proper justification can be deemed bad faith.
  • Unreasonable Delays: Prolonging the claims process unnecessarily can impose significant financial burdens on the affected party.
  • Inadequate Investigations: Neglecting to thoroughly investigate a claim using all accessible evidence is improper.
  • Low Settlement Offers: Proposing amounts that undervalue your claim may pressure you into pursuing litigation.

 

Evaluating Your Coverage

If you own a high-value property or business, assessing whether your insurance agent has provided adequate coverage for your unique situation is vital. While agents should exercise reasonable care, they are not necessarily obligated to point out every possible flaw in your coverage. Therefore, it's important for policyholders to carefully review their insurance documentation.

The Special Relationship Exception

In cases involving high-value assets, a "special relationship" may exist between the policyholder and the agent, which elevates the agent's duty of care. Courts often consider:

  • Whether the agent has offered specialized advice concerning unique risks.
  • If you placed trust in the agent's expertise regarding your coverage.
  • The extent of discretion the agent has in managing your coverage.
  • Assurances regarding coverage for specific valuables can complicate disputes over coverage.

 

Experienced Representation for Water Damage Claims in Northwest Indiana

At Ashford DiMartino & Jones, our expertise lies in helping clients throughout Northwest Indiana navigate the complexities of water damage claims. Whether you are facing significant damages to your residence, business interruptions, or an unresponsive insurance provider, our skilled legal team is dedicated to advocating for your rights.

(Note: We also have dedicated hubs for our neighbors in surrounding cities in Northwest Indiana.)

Meet Your Northwest Indiana Insurance Coverage Attorneys

C. Anthony “Tony” Ashford

Partner / Ashford DiMartino & Jones

Guy S. DiMartino

Partner / Ashford DiMartino & Jones

Angela M. Jones

Partner / Ashford DiMartino & Jones

Our Experience Works for You


C. Anthony “Tony” Ashford and Guy S. DiMartino each offer more than 20 years of legal experience representing clients in complex insurance matters. Over the years, they have negotiated settlements, handled challenging litigation, spoken on insurance-related issues, and served as both inside and outside counsel for businesses. Together, they focus on protecting families, businesses, and organizations—including homeowners and condominium associations—facing insurance disputes or coverage concerns.

Angela M. Jones is an accomplished trial attorney with over a decade of experience in personal injury, commercial litigation, business matters, and municipal law. Known for her strategic approach and strong advocacy, she is dedicated to achieving results for clients facing difficult legal challenges.

In 2024, Angela secured an $8.25 million jury verdict in Cosme v. Erie Insurance, a high-profile bad faith case that ranked among Indiana’s largest verdicts of the year. She also obtained a unanimous 5-0 decision from the Indiana Supreme Court prior to trial, reinforcing her ability to hold insurers accountable and deliver meaningful results in complex cases.

Ready to Take Action? Contact Our Firm Today

When facing a catastrophic loss due to severe storms, you need advocates on your side. Reach out to Ashford DiMartino & Jones today. Protect your property, safeguard your business, and allow our experienced trial attorneys to hold your insurance company accountable.

Get A Free Claim Review





    Get in Touch

    (219) 728-5210
    guy@ashforddimartino.com

    Locations

    336 W. 806 N.
    Valparaiso, IN 46385