Merrillville Property Damage Attorneys
When a major severe storm with high winds, floods, or a fire damage your home or business in Merrillville, your property insurance should act as a dependable path toward recovery. However, handling complex, high-value insurance claims can be difficult and often becomes stressful. If your insurance provider is denying coverage for your commercial property, delaying payouts, or offering undervalued settlements, the experienced attorneys at Ashford DiMartino & Jones are ready to step in and protect your interests.

Our Local Indiana Team Fights For YOU
Expert Guidance: Navigating Your Property Damage Claim
We’ve compiled the following resources to help you understand your rights, hold insurers accountable, and maximize your recovery in Merrillville.
Table of Contents
Merrillville, Indiana: Trusted Attorneys for Property Damage and Insurance Claims

Experiencing a catastrophic loss, such as a sudden fire that destroys your home or severe storms that cause extensive damage to your business, can be overwhelming. In such scenarios, property insurance should ideally facilitate your recovery. However, the complexities involved in large insurance claims can often prove challenging. If your insurer is stalling on payments, proposing unsatisfactory settlements, or denying coverage for your commercial property, the committed legal team at Ashford DiMartino & Jones is ready to assist you.
Based in Merrillville, we proudly serve the entire Northwest Indiana region, advocating for individuals and businesses facing insurance-related dilemmas and challenging claim processes. Our expertise extends to public adjusters striving to secure fair payments on behalf of their clients.
Navigating Property Insurance in Indiana
Insurance policies function as contracts between policyholders and insurers, but they can often appear complex and intimidating. Fortunately, Indiana law offers protections aimed at leveling the playing field for both individuals and commercial property owners in Merrillville.
The Rule of Ambiguity in Policy Language
Insurance agreements often contain ambiguous clauses, which can lead to confusion concerning terms like "storm damage" or "accidental loss." Under Indiana law, when policy language invites multiple interpretations, courts typically side with policyholders.
Policyholder-Friendly Interpretations
Indiana's legal system interprets policy language from the viewpoint of a layperson rather than that of a legal expert. This approach safeguards policyholders by ensuring they are not compelled to navigate convoluted technical terminology when advocating for legitimate claims.
Enforcement of Clear Policy Language
In cases where an insurance policy's language is unambiguous and straightforward, Indiana courts uphold those terms as written, irrespective of how they may limit coverage in specific instances.
Holding Insurers Accountable
In Indiana, all insurance policies carry an implied obligation of good faith, mandating insurers to treat clients fairly throughout the claims process. Bad faith practices—such as:
- Unjustly denying legitimate claims.
- Unduly prolonging the assessment or payment process following catastrophic events in Merrillville.
- Conducting superficial investigations before denying claims.
- Offering settlements that undervalue damages, which can compel policyholders to resort to litigation—can inflict significant financial distress on those facing substantial losses.
Assessing Your Coverage Needs
For both homeowners and businesses in Merrillville, insufficient insurance coverage can lead to financial hardship. While insurance agents are expected to exercise reasonable diligence in securing coverage, they are not mandated to recommend every available option or guarantee comprehensive protection. Policyholders must actively review their insurance documents; if they discover gaps in critical coverage—such as business interruption insurance—they may bear some responsibility.
The “Special Relationship” Exception
In particular situations, an insurance agent may owe a heightened duty of care if a "special relationship" is established. Courts evaluate factors including:
- Whether the agent provides tailored advice addressing unique risks (such as those particular to commercial operations in Merrillville).
- Whether the agent is viewed as an authority, and the client trusts that expertise.
- Whether the agent exerts significant influence over the selection and management of the client's insurance policy.
If an agent makes explicit assurances—such as confirming that high-value personal property or commercial activities are sufficiently insured, and the policyholder relies on those assurances—they might be held legally accountable.
High-Value Property Damage Claims We Handle in Merrillville
Our firm specializes in handling complex property damage claims. Whether you manage a commercial operation, own a luxury home, or lead a condominium association, our legal team is equipped to manage intricate litigation across Merrillville and surrounding areas.
Commercial Claims:
We assist businesses in Merrillville confronting significant disruptions due to property damage, including:
- Fire and smoke damage to commercial spaces.
- Water damage impacting operations.
- Wind damage stemming from severe weather events.
- Claims denied as a result of bad faith practices.
Residential Claims:
We stand by homeowners working to rebuild after severe losses, such as:
- Major residential fires.
- Water damage affecting residences.
- Storm and roof damage to homes.
- Issues arising from bad faith insurance denials.
(Note: We also have dedicated hubs for our neighbors in Crown Point and Highland.)
NWI Service Locations
Meet Your Merrillville Insurance Coverage Attorneys
C. Anthony “Tony” Ashford
Partner / Ashford DiMartino & Jones
Guy S. DiMartino
Partner / Ashford DiMartino & Jones
Angela M. Jones
Partner / Ashford DiMartino & Jones
Your Advocates for Justice
C. Anthony “Tony” Ashford and Guy S. DiMartino each bring over 20 years of legal experience representing clients in complex disputes. Throughout their careers, they have negotiated settlements, litigated challenging cases, delivered presentations on insurance-related issues, and served as both inside and outside counsel for businesses. Together, they are committed to supporting families, businesses, and organizations—including homeowners and condominium associations—facing insurance claim disputes or coverage concerns.
Angela M. Jones is a dedicated trial attorney with more than a decade of experience handling personal injury, business litigation, commercial transactions, and municipal law matters. Known for her strategic approach and relentless advocacy, Angela has built a reputation for achieving strong results in demanding cases.
In 2024, Angela secured an $8.25 million jury verdict in Cosme v. Erie Insurance, a significant insurance bad faith case that gained statewide attention and ranked among Indiana’s largest verdicts of the year. Prior to trial, she obtained a unanimous 5-0 decision from the Indiana Supreme Court. This outcome reflects her ability to hold insurers accountable and deliver justice in complex, high-stakes litigation.
Ready to Fight Back? Contact Our Firm Today
When dealing with a catastrophic commercial loss or the destruction of a high-value home, you cannot afford to let the insurance company dictate your recovery.
Reach out to Ashford DiMartino & Jones today. Protect your property, protect your business, and let our experienced trial attorneys hold the insurance company accountable.
Get A Free Claim Review