Portage Property Damage Attorneys
When a catastrophic flood, fire, or severe storms with damaging winds affect your home or business in Portage, your property insurance should serve as a reliable path to recovery. However, managing complex, high-value insurance claims is often challenging and can quickly become overwhelming. If your insurer is denying coverage for your commercial property, delaying payments, or presenting low settlement offers, the skilled attorneys at Ashford DiMartino & Jones are prepared to step in and advocate for you.

Our Local Indiana Team Fights For YOU
Expert Guidance: Navigating Your Property Damage Claim
We’ve compiled the following resources to help you understand your rights, hold insurers accountable, and maximize your recovery in Portage.
Table of Contents
Portage, Indiana: Your Reliable Attorneys for Property Damage Claims

When unexpected disasters like fires ravage your beloved custom home or severe storms inflict damage on your business, the role of property insurance becomes crucial for your recovery. However, navigating the intricacies of substantial insurance claims can be quite complex. If your insurance provider is delaying payments, providing insufficient settlements, or outright denying coverage for your commercial property, the dedicated legal team at Ashford DiMartino & Jones stands ready to assist.
Serving Portage and the surrounding regions, we are committed to advocating for families, businesses, and community organizations—such as homeowners and condominium associations—facing challenges with insurance claims. We also extend our services to public adjusters experiencing difficulties in obtaining rightful payments for their clients.
Understanding Property Insurance in Indiana
Insurance policies function as contracts between policyholders and insurers, yet they can often come laden with complexities. Fortunately, Indiana law offers essential protections designed to help individuals and commercial property owners in Portage navigate these waters.
The Rule of Ambiguity
Ambiguous language within insurance agreements often results in confusion surrounding terms like "storm damage" or "accidental loss." Indiana law dictates that when the language in a policy allows for multiple interpretations, the benefit of the doubt typically goes to the policyholder.
Interpretation from the Policyholder’s Perspective
Indiana courts interpret policy language through the lens of the average person rather than a legal expert, thereby safeguarding policyholders from being at a disadvantage due to technical jargon.
Clarity in Policy Language
If an insurance policy is clearly articulated, Indiana courts will uphold its terms as written, even if those terms may seem restrictive or unfair under certain circumstances.
Holding Insurers Accountable
In Indiana, all insurance policies are accompanied by an implied duty of good faith, mandating that insurers treat their clients fairly throughout the claims process. In instances involving significant losses, poor practices from insurers can impose severe financial strain. Examples of such behaviors under Indiana’s Unfair Claim Settlement Practices include:
- Wrongfully rejecting valid claims without just cause.
- Unduly prolonging the claims assessment or payment process, particularly after storms or fires impacting Portage.
- Failing to conduct thorough investigations prior to denial of claims.
- Offering settlement amounts that fail to accurately reflect the extent of damage, which may leave policyholders with no choice but to pursue litigation.
Assessing Your Coverage Needs: Are You Underinsured?
Financial difficulties can emerge for property owners in Portage due to insufficient insurance coverage. While insurance agents are expected to exercise reasonable diligence in securing the coverage you request, they are not obligated to recommend every possible option or ensure comprehensive protection. Policyholders should meticulously review their insurance documentation; if critical coverage—such as business interruption insurance—is lacking, the responsibility may fall on them.
The “Special Relationship” Exception
In certain instances, insurance agents may owe a heightened duty of care if a "special relationship" exists. Courts examine factors such as:
- Whether the agent renders specialized advice tailored to unique risks (like those associated with businesses in Portage).
- Whether the agent presents themselves as an authority, leading policyholders to trust their expertise.
- Whether the agent has significant control over the selection and management of your insurance policy.
Additionally, if an agent makes explicit assurances—like confirming that high-value property or commercial activities are fully insured—and a policyholder relies on those statements, liability may ensue.
Types of Major Property Damage Claims We Address in Portage
Our focus is on handling significant property damage claims. Whether you manage a commercial establishment, own a high-value home, or oversee a condominium association, our legal team is prepared to tackle intricate litigation cases across Portage.
Commercial Claims
We support Portage businesses experiencing notable disruptions due to property damage, including:
- Fire and smoke harm to commercial buildings.
- Water damage affecting business operations.
- Storm and wind-related damage to business properties.
- Denials based on bad faith practices.
Residential Claims
We are committed to assisting homeowners as they rebuild after devastating losses, including:
- Major residential fire incidents.
- Water damage impacting homes.
- Roof and storm damage affecting residential properties.
- Bad faith insurance denials troubling homeowners.
(Note: We also have dedicated hubs for our neighbors in Chesterton and Merrillville.)
NWI Service Locations
Meet Your Portage Insurance Coverage Attorneys
C. Anthony “Tony” Ashford
Partner / Ashford DiMartino & Jones
Guy S. DiMartino
Partner / Ashford DiMartino & Jones
Angela M. Jones
Partner / Ashford DiMartino & Jones
Your Advocates for Justice
For over 20 years, C. Anthony “Tony” Ashford and Guy S. DiMartino have represented clients in complex legal matters, including insurance disputes. Their experience includes negotiating settlements, litigating cases, and serving as counsel for businesses. They are committed to protecting families, businesses, and organizations facing insurance challenges.
Angela M. Jones brings over a decade of experience as a trial attorney handling personal injury and commercial litigation. She is recognized for her strategic thinking and strong advocacy.
In 2024, she obtained an $8.25 million verdict in Cosme v. Erie Insurance, along with a unanimous Indiana Supreme Court decision prior to trial.
Ready to Fight Back? Contact Our Firm Today
When dealing with a catastrophic commercial loss or the destruction of a high-value home, you cannot afford to let the insurance company dictate your recovery.
Reach out to Ashford DiMartino & Jones today. Protect your property, protect your business, and let our experienced trial attorneys hold the insurance company accountable.
Get A Free Claim Review