Westville Property Damage Attorneys

When a major fire, severe storm with strong winds, or floods impacts your home or business in Westville, your property insurance should provide a clear path toward recovery. However, managing complex, high-value insurance claims are often anything but simple. If your insurance company is delaying compensation, offering insufficient settlements, or denying coverage for your commercial property, the skilled attorneys at Ashford DiMartino & Jones are ready to step in and advocate on your behalf.

.

 

Our Local Indiana Team Fights For YOU

Quick Case Fact: In 2024, Angela Jones secured an $8.25 million jury verdict in Cosme v. Erie Insurance, an insurance bad faith case that drew statewide attention and recognition, ranking among Indiana’s largest verdicts of the year. 

Expert Guidance: Navigating Your Property Damage Claim

We’ve compiled the following resources to help you understand your rights, hold insurers accountable, and maximize your recovery in Westville.

Westville Property Damage Attorneys

When a fire, severe storm, water loss, or other major event damages your home or business in Westville, Indiana, you expect your insurance policy to help you recover. Unfortunately, property insurance claims do not always move as smoothly as expected. Delayed payments, low estimates, disputed repairs, and denied coverage can make an already difficult situation even more stressful.

Ashford DiMartino & Jones helps Westville homeowners, businesses, landlords, and other property owners navigate significant property damage insurance claims. When an insurance company's offer does not reflect the documented loss, our attorneys can review the claim and help protect the recovery available under the policy.

Helping Property Owners in Westville and Northwest Indiana

Ashford DiMartino & Jones serves clients throughout Westville, LaPorte County, and Northwest Indiana who are facing insurance disputes after substantial property damage.

Our firm assists homeowners, business owners, commercial property owners, landlords, property managers, condominium and homeowners associations, and other organizations. We can also provide legal guidance to public adjusters when a significant property loss develops into a coverage or payment dispute.

Understanding Your Indiana Property Insurance Policy

Your insurance policy is a contract that establishes the coverage available after a loss. These policies can include detailed definitions, exclusions, limits, deductibles, and conditions that affect how a claim is evaluated.

When disagreements develop between a policyholder and insurance company, Indiana law provides principles for determining how policy language should be interpreted.

When Insurance Policy Language Is Unclear

Some insurance provisions can reasonably be understood in more than one way. Questions may arise over the cause of damage, whether a particular loss is covered, or how an exclusion applies.

When policy language is genuinely ambiguous, Indiana courts generally interpret that ambiguity in favor of the insured rather than allowing an insurer to benefit from unclear wording.

How an Ordinary Policyholder Would Understand the Policy

Insurance policies are generally interpreted based on how an ordinary policyholder would reasonably understand the language, rather than relying only on highly technical interpretations.

This can become important when an insurance company relies on complicated terminology to reduce or deny coverage for a property damage claim.

Clear Policy Language Still Matters

Not every coverage disagreement means the policy is ambiguous. When the terms clearly establish a limitation, requirement, or exclusion, Indiana courts generally enforce the policy as written.

Carefully reviewing the actual policy language is therefore an important part of evaluating a disputed insurance claim.

Fair Treatment During the Insurance Claim Process

Insurance companies in Indiana have an obligation to handle claims fairly and in good faith. After a major property loss, unnecessary delays or inadequate payments can create serious financial problems for families and businesses trying to repair or rebuild.

Potential concerns with an insurance company's handling of a claim may include:

  • Denying a claim without reasonable grounds
  • Unnecessarily delaying an investigation or payment
  • Failing to reasonably investigate the loss
  • Offering a settlement below the documented damage
  • Overlooking contractor estimates or other evidence
  • Disputing repairs necessary to restore the property
  • Creating unnecessary obstacles during the claim

These issues can become especially significant following substantial fire damage, water damage, storm damage, wind damage, or other covered property losses.

What If Your Insurance Coverage Falls Short?

Discovering that your insurance coverage may be inadequate after a serious loss can leave a Westville homeowner or business responsible for substantial expenses.

Insurance agents generally have responsibilities when obtaining coverage specifically requested by their customers. However, an agent is not automatically required to recommend every available coverage option or guarantee that a policy protects against every possible loss.

Property owners should periodically review important parts of their policies, including coverage limits, deductibles, exclusions, replacement cost provisions, and business interruption coverage when applicable.

Significant Property Damage Claims in Westville

Ashford DiMartino & Jones represents clients dealing with substantial property losses and complex insurance disputes throughout Westville, LaPorte County, and Northwest Indiana.

Whether the loss involves a residence, rental property, business, commercial building, or association-managed property, disagreements can arise over the extent of damage, repair costs, replacement values, coverage, and the amount the insurance company is willing to pay.

Commercial Property Insurance Claims

Westville businesses and commercial property owners may experience losses involving:

  • Commercial Fire & Smoke Damage
  • Commercial Water Damage
  • Commercial Storm & Wind Damage
  • Commercial Property Insurance Claims
  • Business Interruption Disputes
  • Commercial "Bad Faith" Insurance Denials

For a business, property damage can affect more than the building itself. Equipment, inventory, employees, operations, and revenue may all be impacted while repairs are underway.

Residential Property Insurance Claims

Ashford DiMartino & Jones also assists Westville homeowners with significant residential claims involving:

  • Large-Loss Residential Fire Damage
  • Residential Water Damage
  • Residential Storm & Wind Damage
  • Roof Damage Insurance Claims
  • Significant Personal Property Losses
  • Residential "Bad Faith" Insurance Denials

A serious loss can leave a family dealing with damaged belongings, temporary housing, contractors, repairs, and insurance questions at the same time. The amount recovered through the claim can directly affect the ability to properly restore the home.

Property Damage Insurance Help for Westville, Indiana

When an insurance company's estimate, coverage decision, or payment does not reflect the documented loss, property owners do not necessarily have to accept the initial decision without asking questions.

Ashford DiMartino & Jones helps Westville homeowners, businesses, landlords, commercial property owners, and organizations understand their insurance policies and evaluate disputes involving substantial property damage.

Whether the claim involves fire damage, water damage, storm damage, wind damage, roof damage, commercial property damage, or a disputed property insurance claim in Westville, Indiana, our attorneys can help evaluate the insurance company's position and pursue the recovery available under the policy.

(Note: We also have dedicated hubs for our neighbors in Valparaiso and Michigan City.)

Meet Your Chesterton Insurance Coverage Attorneys

C. Anthony “Tony” Ashford

Partner / Ashford DiMartino & Jones

Guy S. DiMartino

Partner / Ashford DiMartino & Jones

Angela M. Jones

Partner / Ashford DiMartino & Jones

Our Expertise is Your Asset

C. Anthony “Tony” Ashford and Guy S. DiMartino each bring more than 20 years of legal experience to their clients. Throughout their careers, they have negotiated favorable settlements, handled complex litigation, presented on insurance law topics, and served as both in-house and outside counsel for businesses. Together, they focus on protecting families, businesses, and organizations—including homeowners and condominium associations—who have insurance policy concerns or disputes with their providers.

Angela M. Jones is a highly skilled trial attorney with over a decade of experience representing clients in personal injury, commercial litigation, business transactions, and municipal law. Recognized for her strategic thinking and strong courtroom presence, Angela is known as a determined advocate who delivers results in even the most challenging cases.

In 2024, Angela obtained an $8.25 million jury verdict in Cosme v. Erie Insurance, a significant insurance bad faith case that gained statewide recognition and ranked among Indiana’s largest verdicts of the year. Before trial, she secured a unanimous 5-0 decision at the Indiana Supreme Court. This result highlights her ability to hold insurers accountable and achieve justice in complex, high-stakes matters.

 

Ready to Fight Back? Contact Our Firm Today

When facing a major commercial loss or significant damage to a high-value home, you should not allow the insurance company to control the outcome of your recovery.

Contact Ashford DiMartino & Jones today. Safeguard your property, protect your business, and let our skilled trial attorneys pursue accountability against the insurance company.

Get A Free Claim Review





    Get in Touch

    (219) 728-5210
    guy@ashforddimartino.com

    Locations

    336 W. 806 N.
    Valparaiso, IN 46385